
壬生義士伝 Mibu Gishi Den
(English Title: When The Last Sword is Drawn)
Winner “Best Film” Japanese Academy Awards
Winner “Best Actor” Japanese Academy Awards
Winner “Best Supporting Actor” Japanese Academy Awards
Release Date:
18 January 2003 (Japan)
Late one Tokyo night in the winter of 1899, as Dr Ono Chiaki (Takehiro Murata) and his wife are packing to move their small medical clinic to Manchuria, they are visited by an elderly man with an ill grandson. Amidst the chaos of packing crates and boxes, the man, Saito Hajime (Koich Sato), spots an old photograph of a samurai, Yoshimura Kanichiro (Kiichi Nakai), whom he recognizes from some thirty years earlier. The photo triggers in both Ono and Saito a series of complex memories of Yoshimura as the incarnation of the samurai's heroic code at a time when such a code was fast becoming an irrelevant detail of history.
Along with Yamada Yoji’s superior The Twilight Samurai (2002) and Edward Zwick's entertaining The Last Samurai (2003), Takita Yojiro’s “When the Last Sword is Drawn” or “Mibu Gishi Den”, set in the same period, forms part of a growing body of revisionist literary and cinematic works that re-examine samurai values in their death throes - in much the same way that revisionist westerns like Sam Peckinpah's 'The Wild Bunch' (1969) and Clint Eastwood's 'Unforgiven' (1992) reexamined the rapidly vanishing ideology of the cowboy. In Takita's film, Yoshimura is depicted at the outset as a deeply unconventional samurai - clownish, obsessed with money, unconcerned with saving face, and always valuing wife and children over clan, life over death. The more traditional Saito's first recollections of Yoshimura are as "the man I hated most", "an awful country samurai bragging about home and family" - and his first impulse upon meeting him was to kill him on the spot. "What kind of samurai is that?" becomes a recurring question.
The younger Ono, on the other hand, who as a boy lived in the same provincial town as Yoshimura, remembers him more sympathetically as "strong and gentle", a wise teacher and a skilled swordsman who deserted the local clan and sought work in Kyoto for the Shinshengumi (a special police force of the late Tokugawa Period) to prevent his family from starving to death. As Saito and Ono begin to share drinks and memories privately with the audience, their view of the man in the photo starts to shift subtly, and the narrative that they weave together transforms a mercenary buffoon, and the shabbily pointless end that he meets, into a heroic example of samurai virtues whose crowning glory is an act of extraordinary self-sacrifice.
The cinematography is excellent and while the editing has a few “bumps” the story moves well and draws the viewer in. The dialog and acting is straightforward with no “tricks” in the characters or plot, thus making it a thoroughly enjoyable movie. There are, within the film, scenes of great violence and brutality (one of the reasons we watch Samurai films ne) but there are also scenes of great dedication, love and compassion, as well as futility, which will bring tears to the eyes of even the most jaded viewer.
Commentary:
NAKAI KIICHI (Yoshimura)
“The Shinsengumi provides a historical background. As I understand it, love toward friends and family is the main theme of the film. In this modern society, when you say, “stick to our conscience”; I wonder what is meant by “conscience” and wonder if people actually do have a conscience. I realized that in this society, how other people perceive you is more important. It seems really important how you see yourself within this society, but actually, how you want to live should be more important than what others think of you.
“You must have your own philosophy on life. In my role as Yoshimura…he sticks to his own way. This might be for his family because he loves his family and wants to protect them. It is not because he should protect them but because he wants to.
I hope through this film, people could see the importance of having their own principles. For the young generation and for my own generation, it is necessary to find and stick to our own philosophy for the future of Japanese society.
SATO KOICHI (SAITO HAJIME)
“I understand the samurai spirit to be like the soul of young boys who have difficulty accepting societal rules. The film describes the conflict which Yoshimura has to face between his samurai spirit and his responsibilities towards his family…this is the matter of conflict which Yoshimura has to face. First he tries to refuse accepting the societal rules but gradually compromises to survive as a real man.”
TAKITA YOJIRO (DIRECTOR)
Question: What was the “trigger “ for making the film?
“I was asked by the producers…I was reading the novel for awhile when it was serialized in a magazine. Then I read the whole story again before making the film. It was amazing. I t made me cry…thinking that I had become hold…but I doubt if there is anyone who would not cry. I am sure everyone would.
Question: What is the most important part of the film?
“That’s it. I believe this film is not only about the Shinsengumi. Even in today’s society, men like Yoshimura absolutely exist. This film is refreshing because it makes us aware that men like Yoshimura exist and are needed in our society.
“It is difficult to explain conscience but I was really attracted to his spirit…if you read the novel you would realize what I realized. I realized I could ask myself “could I live according to my own conscience?”
“I am glad I knew about this novel. It gave me a good chance to think about my job and my role as a film director.
ASADA JIRO (AUTHOR)
“People have pride. Because of this pride the samurai tried to hide what they really felt. This, I think, made them heroes…but Yoshimura was different. He was honest. If he didn’t have money he would say so. He made money by killing people to support his family. He didn’t care about his pride or social status.
“I tried to imagine what he was like and I created his character in my head. I created the “ideal” man. In real life, it might be impossible to find such a man as a husband and as a father. When I think of him it tells me how I should live, as a man, as a husband, and as a father even though I created him myself.
“I wanted to write a story about the least heroic Shinsengumi. For me the worst and the least heroic samurai is the coolest one.
“What are our real responsibilities or duties as a human being? That is what I wanted to convey to readers. In this modern society, although people may already know what they really should do, most are unable to do it because there are so many temptations. At Any time and in any kind of society, what is important for us is the same. I wanted to describe people who do the right thing.
“Another important thing in the story is the love for his [Yoshimura] for his home province. It is one of the main themes of the story. I feel that in the whole world it is only the Japanese people who do not appreciate tat we are Japanese. We have become half-American. In the story, I describe Yoshimura’s love for the province of Morioka. However, what I aimed for is to remind readers of their hometown…or even, in a broader sense, of Japan.”
(c) 2007 Hayato Tokugawa